Competing visions in urban reserve talks

Two competing maps show the latest political battle lines in years-long planning effort

By Christian Gaston

The Forest Grove News-Times, Dec 17, 2009

Chase Allgood / News-Times

Portland Mayor Sam Adams (left, center) and Washington County Chair Tom Brian wrangled over the issue of urban reserves Monday night in the Hillsboro Civic Center.

ADVERTISEMENTS

For more than two years regional leaders have been trying to hash out what land should be set aside for urban development in the next 50 years and what should stay rural.

Over the past month, those talks have gotten stickier, with Tualatin and West Linn sending a strongly-worded letter opposing the urbanization of the Stafford area south of Lake Oswego and some county commissioners questioning the whole process.

But Wednesday, Metro President David Bragdon and Metro Councilor Carl Hosticka said the time to act is now. And they drew a map to show the way.

The next day, Metro Councilors Robert Liberty and Rod Park issued their own map, which made a similar centrist pitch on where the region should grow-largely eschewing controversial areas like Helvetia and the heart of the Tualatin plain north of Forest Grove-but would set aside much less land for urban development.

The Bragdon-Hosticka map, if adopted, would mean the region would set aside 28,000 acres of urban reserves to use as cities expand over the next 40 or 50 years. Liberty and Park's map identifies 18,700 acres.

But in a split vote on Thursday, Metro councilors voted to back the Bragdon-Hosticka map.

Liberty and Metro Councilor Rex Burkholder voted against the Bragdon-Hosticka map. Park abstained.

“Our intention is to accelerate discussion through having a specific proposal on the table to which people can react," said Hosticka at the Thursday meeting, according to a Metro press release.

The map, called the Bragdon/Hosticka Map is similar to a map of initial agreement drawn up by the “Core 4,” a group of representatives from Clackamas, Multnomah and Washington Counties and Metro.

But it also makes some bold suggestions:

• Land north of Cornelius between Council and Dairy Creek, west of Cornelius Schefflin Rd. is recommended as an urban reserve, while urban reserves for land south of Cornelius is significantly pared back.

• Forest Grove gets a small portion of land north of its boundaries bounded by Purdin Rd. in the north and Highway 47 on the east.

1 | 2 Next Page >>